CAN A LIE BE MEANINGFUL? A PHILOSOPHICAL ANALYSIS OF LYING AND TRUTH IN HUMAN COMMUNICATION

Penulis

  • Icha Anggraini Samosir Universitas Negeri Medan
  • Gracesya Natali Jeniffer S Universitas Negeri Medan
  • Anggi Kasih Silalahi Universitas Negeri Medan
  • Ayla Claudia Br Sitepu Universitas Negeri Medan

Kata Kunci:

Lying, Truth, Human Communication, Trust, Ethics Of Care, Phenomenology, Digital Literacy

Abstrak

Lies and truth are inseparable parts of human communication, but the two do not always present themselves as simple opposites. In social life and the evolution of digital communication, a person may convey untruths not only to deceive, but also to protect feelings, avoid conflict, maintain relationships, or cope with situations deemed difficult. This study aims to philosophically analyze the meanings of lying and truth in human communication by examining individuals’ experiences, perceptions, and reflections on the acts of lying and telling the truth. The study employs an interpretive qualitative approach with a phenomenological orientation to understand the meaning of communicative experiences from the participants’ perspectives. Data were collected through semi-structured in-depth interviews with number adult participants who had direct experience in telling, receiving, or witnessing lies in interpersonal communication, and were supported by an analysis of relevant literature. The data were analyzed thematically to identify patterns of meaning and interpret them through a phenomenological perspective, truth-default theory, and the ethics of care. The results revealed four main patterns: lying as a form of protection, lying as a source of emotional burden, the reciprocal relationship between lying and trust, and truth as a contextual and relational choice. These findings suggest that lying can have personal and relational meanings without automatically being morally justified. Theoretically, this study expands our understanding of lying as a dynamic and meaningful communicative act, while practically, it underscores the importance of education in communication ethics, digital literacy, and strengthening relationships that enable honesty to be conveyed responsibly and empathetically.

 

Unduhan

Diterbitkan

2026-10-31